There’s something almost mythical about Tiger Woods and his understanding of golf. The 15-time major champion sees shots, feels swings, and processes the game at a level so advanced that most cannot comprehend. His supernatural talent has dazzled fans for decades, creating moments of brilliance that defy explanation. But could that same transcendent genius actually be a limitation when it comes to teaching others?

That’s the fascinating claim made by hosts Frankie and Trent of the Fore Play Podcast. when asked about a hypothetical scenario: What if  Scottie Scheffler’s had Tiger Woods on the bag? Would the combination of Scheffler’s elite skill and Woods’s unparalleled knowledge create an unstoppable force in golf? According to the podcast hosts, the answer is a surprising and definitive no—Woods would actually be a hindrance rather than a help on Scheffler’s bag.

Tiger Woods: The grandmaster who speaks a different language

“I don’t think Tiger is a very good teacher,” the hosts claimed during the discussion, suggesting that Woods’s unparalleled mastery creates a communication barrier. “He’s the wizard, he’s the Dumbledore, he’s the grandmaster of golf. He knows everything; he knows how every single aspect of the body and the club maneuvers its way to get that ball in the hole.”

The hosts theorized that Woods’s natural genius and instinctive understanding made it nearly impossible for him to relate to how “normal” elite players—even someone as accomplished as world #1 Scheffler—approach the game. They explained that the greatest athletes often struggle to teach others because their skill comes naturally to them. Furthermore, they suggested that Woods might say something like, “Yeah, I won 15 majors, and I won a bunch of them by a million strokes. I just had to do these things, and it was that easy.” But what comes easy to Woods remains elusive even to other top professionals.

Scottie Scheffler Comes Clean on Undue ‘Advantage’ Amid a Grueling Test for PGA Tour Pros at Bay Hill

This sentiment isn’t without precedent; a disconnect was evident during a Fore Play video where Woods gave golf tips. The hosts recounted how Woods’s instructions were consistently framed through his own unique perspective: “Everything that he said to us was like what he would do in that situation. ‘Oh, here I’d take a little pitching wedge, and I would just bump it right here.’”The problem? His advice, while technically sound, wasn’t presented in a way that acknowledged the skill gap between himself and average players. Woods has mentored a few young players. However, despite his 29 years of professional experience, he has never taken a single player under his wing for long-term technical coaching.

This applies not only to golf and Tiger Woods but also to all sports and their legends.

When greatness becomes a barrier: The historical struggle of legends as teachers

Tiger Woods isn’t the only one facing this challenge. Throughout sports history, transcendent talents have struggled to translate their intuitive mastery into effective teaching.

This pattern extends beyond golf into other sports. Basketball legend Magic Johnson’s brief coaching stint with the Lakers resulted in a disappointing 5-11 record as he grew frustrated with players who couldn’t execute at his level. NFL great Mike Singletary struggled as the San Francisco 49ers head coach with an 18-22 record, unable to instill the same instinctive defensive brilliance that made him a Hall of Fame linebacker. What connects these stories is their reliance on subconscious excellence—something these sporting greats couldn’t fully explain.

Whether this assessment of Woods’s teaching capabilities is accurate remains open for debate. But it highlights a fascinating paradox in sports: the very qualities that made Woods the greatest golfer of his generation might make him ineffective at communicating that knowledge to others. What’s your take? Would Woods’s legendary wisdom help or hurt Scheffler’s game? Let us know in the comments section below!